By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
October 29, 2025 5:14 AM EDT
Medical Herald
Search
  • Health Conditions
    Health ConditionsShow More
    Beware of Counterfeit Weight Loss Drugs Sold Online
    Weight Management
    Father’s Back Pain Leads to Tragic Cancer Diagnosis
    Cancer
    Novo Nordisk’s CEO Emphasizes Strategic Risks to Lead Obesity Market
    Weight Management
    Medtronic Launches Ankle Implant for Bladder Control
    Health Conditions
    Stewart’s Caring Place Highlights All Cancer Awareness in October
    Breast Cancer
  • Wellness & Self-Care
    Wellness & Self-CareShow More
    Jewel Reflects on Fame and Mental Health Advocacy Journey
    Mental Health
    Discover the Health Benefits of Hazelnuts
    Healthy Living
    How the Government Shutdown Affects Health Insurance Costs
    Wellness & Self-Care
    NYC Sues Tech Giants Over Youth Mental Health Crisis
    Mental Health
    Understanding Deep and REM Sleep: Essential for Recovery
    Wellness & Self-Care
  • Nutrition & Fitness
    Nutrition & FitnessShow More
    Calcium Loaf: A Depression-Era Recipe for Today’s Food Challenges
    Healthy Recipes
    Effective Full-Body Workout Enhances Testosterone and Muscle
    Fitness
    Impact of the Carnivore Diet on Your Health
    Diet & Nutrition
    Boost Your Mobility: Charley Hull’s Top 3 Workout Routines
    Fitness
    California Takes Bold Step to Improve School Nutrition
    Diet & Nutrition
  • Innovation
    InnovationShow More
    How ALV-J Virus Bypasses Immune Defense Using miR-155
    Innovation
    Nursing Homes’ Use of Painkillers and Antidepressants Raises Risks
    Drugs & Medications
    FDA to Decide on Biohaven’s Ataxia Treatment in November
    Drugs & Medications
    Study Links Bumper Stickers to Aggressive Driving Behavior
    Innovation
    China Achieves First Pig-to-Human Liver Transplant
    Innovation
  • News
    NewsShow More
    St. Joseph Plans New Community Center and Cannabis Dispensary
    News
    Harry and Meghan Shine at World Mental Health Day Gala in NYC
    News
    Emergency Medicaid for Undocumented Immigrants: A Costly Misconception
    News
    Poll Shows Public Skepticism Toward Trump’s Health Claims
    News
    NYC’s Food Insecurity Crisis: Students Need More Than Education
    News
Font ResizerAa
Medical HeraldMedical Herald
  • Health Conditions
  • Wellness & Self-Care
  • Nutrition & Fitness
  • Innovation
  • News
Search
  • Health Conditions
  • Wellness & Self-Care
  • Nutrition & Fitness
  • Innovation
  • News
Follow US
Copyright © 2025, Medical Herald. All Rights Reserved.
Home » Nutrition & Fitness » Fitness » Ninth Circuit Upholds Ruling Against San Diego’s Yoga Ban

Ninth Circuit Upholds Ruling Against San Diego’s Yoga Ban

By Liam Fraser
Published: October 7, 2025
Share

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit has decided not to revisit its previous ruling that invalidated San Diego’s ban on group yoga classes held in public parks and along beaches. This unanimous decision is particularly notable as it signals strong consensus among the judges, effectively upholding the earlier ruling and leaving the city’s restrictions unenforceable.

This legal victory is particularly significant for local yoga instructors Steve Hubbard, known as “NamaSteve,” and Amy Baack, who initiated the lawsuit against the city last year.

In June, a three-judge panel ruled decisively that the act of teaching yoga is a form of protected speech under the First Amendment. The panel concluded that city officials failed to provide sufficient evidence that yoga classes posed a risk to public safety or hindered the enjoyment of the city’s parks and beaches, overturning a previous lower court’s ruling.

Following this ruling, the city’s decision to appeal resulted in a formal order from the Ninth Circuit on Monday. When contacted for comments, a representative from the City Attorney’s Office declined to provide any details regarding the appeal.

The origins of this legal dispute trace back to San Diego’s 2024 amendment to its street vendor ordinance. This amendment aimed to clarify which activities would qualify for free-speech protections in public spaces. A state law passed in 2018 had decriminalized sidewalk vending, allowing cities to create limited regulations focusing on health and safety, not on excluding vendors.

City officials argued that yoga classes, even when offered for free or donations, should be classified as a commercial activity that does not receive First Amendment protection. They compared yoga to more traditional commercial activities, such as massage therapy, dog training, and fitness classes, claiming these activities could obstruct pathways and access to scenic views.

Officials highlighted the concern that residents had expressed over what they perceived as increasing commercialization in their favorite parks and beaches, including yoga sessions.

In response, Hubbard and Baack filed their lawsuit in federal court in June 2024, asserting that yoga is not a commercial service but rather an expressive activity deserving of protection under the First Amendment. They emphasized that their classes are open to anyone, with donations being optional. “One could simply walk up and join a yoga class in a park,” stated their lawsuit.

Additionally, the lawsuit pointed out that the city had failed to consult the community or include public input regarding the ban through town councils or planning groups. Prior to the ban, Hubbard had been conducting free outdoor yoga sessions at Palisades Park for nearly two decades without any issues. Following the enforcement of the ban, he transitioned to teaching on YouTube; however, he continued to receive citations because participants gathered in the park to practice yoga while following his classes online.

In light of the ongoing legal battles, Hubbard and Baack are pursuing damages, claiming that the city’s actions were retaliatory in nature. They also have a separate state lawsuit arguing that yoga should be classified as an expressive activity protected by the California Constitution.

Bryan Pease, who represents the plaintiffs alongside his partner Parisa Ijadi-Maghsoodi, criticized the city’s focus, stating, “The city clearly does not actually care about public safety or protecting the cliffs. Rangers could be citing illegal fishing, where men climb all over the cliffs and leave behind plastic pollution and fishing line that strangles wildlife. Instead, they were laser-focused on shutting down yoga.”

This case highlights the larger conversation about public access to recreational spaces and the balance between commercial regulation and the protection of free expression in communal areas. As the city’s yoga ban stands undone, the implications of this ruling may resonate beyond San Diego, influencing similar cases across the nation.Fitness & Wellness

TAGGED:Yoga
Share This Article
Facebook LinkedIn Email Copy Link
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

HOT NEWS

Jewel Reflects on Fame and Mental Health Advocacy Journey

October 28, 2025

Beware of Counterfeit Weight Loss Drugs Sold Online

Counterfeit weight loss drugs are flooding the web, prompting FDA warnings as fake GLP-1 products…

October 28, 2025

Father’s Back Pain Leads to Tragic Cancer Diagnosis

Steve Burrows, 38, mistook back pain for aging before learning it was advanced rectal cancer.…

October 28, 2025

Novo Nordisk’s CEO Emphasizes Strategic Risks to Lead Obesity Market

Novo Nordisk’s $5.2B Akero deal marks CEO Mike Doustdar’s bold strategy to dominate obesity and…

October 28, 2025

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

Savy King Shares Health Journey After Cardiac Rehab Return

Savy King begins training again after her shocking on-field heart attack, as Angel City FC faces playoff pressure with four…

October 2, 2025

Candice Swanepoel Shares Yoga Tips in Stylish Leotard

Candice Swanepoel stuns fans with her yoga workout, combining flexibility, strength, and eco-friendly fashion from her sustainable brand, Tropic of…

October 16, 2025

Discover the Benefits of a 15-Minute Pilates Core Workout

Lilly Sabri’s 15-minute Pilates session targets the deep core and glutes, blending controlled strength training with mindful stretching.

October 10, 2025

Transform Your Core: A Quick 10-Minute Bodyweight Workout

A quick, equipment-free 10-minute ab workout that builds core strength, boosts balance, and helps sculpt your abs—perfect for home fitness…

October 22, 2025

Medical Herald is your trusted source for medical news, scientific research, health policy updates, and expert insights from around the world. 

Category

  • Health Conditions
  • Wellness & Self-Care
  • Nutrition & Fitness
  • Innovation
  • News
  • Privacy Policy
  • About Us
  • Contact

Follow US: 

  • Grow Big Agency Sites:
  • London Business Journal
Copyright © 2025, Medical Herald. All Rights Reserved.
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?