The 5 Best Scar Treatment and Removal Creams of 2023 – A Buyer’s Guide

Looking for the most effective way to reduce the overall appearance of scars and improve skin tone? We found the answers.

Many people choose to wear their scars as a badge of honor, while others want to get rid of their scars. If you fall in the second category, we’ve got you covered. You’ll be glad to know that you can effectively minimize the appearance of your scars with the right scar treatment products.

These products help you achieve beautiful and even skin by regenerating the connective tissue below the scar, aiding in the formation of collagen and renewing skin cells.

The problem is, as word got out about the popularity of scar treatment products, skincare brands flooded the market with more products. And in reality: not all scar treatment products are created equal.

You see, because of how stubborn scars are, only a few ingredients have proven to actually be effective in minimizing scars. That’s why it’s crucial to know which ingredients actually work – and which ones are just filler ingredients when you’re choosing one for yourself. 

We’ve done all the work so you don’t have to. We analyzed the top scar treatment products in the market by comparing their ingredients, results and reliability. Now, we’re going to first share what to look out for when you’re shopping for a product, what to avoid and our top 5 choices for scar treatment products in the market.

Reduces the overall appearance of scars

Eliminates redness

Reduces the appearance of stretch marks, scar tissue and uneven pigmentation

Promotes an overall brighter, more even and radiant complexion

Encourages wound healing, collagen production and overall smoothness

Improves skin texture

Why You Need A Scar Treatment Cream

Feel more confident in your own skin

Visible acne scars often make people conscious of their body. That’s why people seek out scar treatment products. By minimizing the appearance of scars, evening out your skin tone and improving your skin texture, these products help you carry yourself with confidence.

Aids in the production of collagen

Collagen is the most abundant protein in your body. It plays a role in strengthening skin, as well as in elasticity and hydration. As you age, your body produces less collagen, leading to dry skin and the formation of wrinkles. The ingredients in scar treatment products also aid in the production of collagen to help you overcome this.

Nourishes your skin

Even the best supplements don’t work for 100% of the people. So, the supplement company you’re buying from should be confident enough in their products to offer a strong no-questions-asked guarantee. Choose products from companies with at least a 30-day money back guarantee. And preferably, a 90-day guarantee.

What To Look For In A Scar Treatment Cream

Vitamin C

Vitamin C has been shown to promote wound healing, also by contributing to collagen formation. Mild to moderate acne scars as well as surgical scars can benefit from a vitamin C application.


Tripeptides have proven to minimize the appearance of scars and prevent additional scarring


Retinol is a well-known ingredient that promotes skin cell turnover and collagen production treating post-acne hyperpigmentation and minimizing the appearance of scars.


Allantoin helps skin to heal more quickly and to bind moisture more effectively, making products containing Allantoin useful for many skin conditions, including scar treatment.

Hydrolysed soy protein

Hydrolysed soy protein protects and repairs the skin through the antioxidant effects of isoflavones. It also acts on the wrinkles, fine lines and the elasticity of the skin.

What To Avoid

Titanium Dioxide

When Titanium Dioxide is exposed to light on your skin, it creates free radicals that in turn ravage your skin, causing skin irritations, acne, and more. That’s why it’s ideal to avoid products that contain Titanium Dioxide.


Paraffin, petroleum, or however it’s labeled in your skincare, is essentially refined petrol. It’s known to clog pores and may also cause heat rashes. It’s particularly harmful for those with sensitive skin.

Top 5 Scar Treatment and Removal Creams

Medical Herald budged
Overall Rating (4.9)
Quality Rating: 9.7/10
Expert Rating: 9.8/10
Users Rating: 9.6/10

Repair: by Regen Health


Repair has a unique blend of ingredients and is designed to reduce the appearance of scars. It also has ingredients that increase collagen content and act on the wrinkles, fine lines and the elasticity of the skin. Plus, it includes ingredients like Pseudoalteromonas Ferment Extract which is a strain of bacteria isolated from mud found on King George Island in Antarctica that have healing properties. Apart from having a solid list of proven ingredients, it’s als reasonably priced at $49.99. Plus, it comes with a comprehensive, 90-day, risk-free, money-back guarantee, proving the company stands behind its products. This, along with the blend of ingredients, puts Repair ahead of all of its competing products.

Learn more
Overall Rating (4.5)
Quality Rating: 9.1/10
Expert Rating: 9.0/10
Users Rating: 8.9/10

Super Serum Advance Plus: by iS Clinical


iS Clinical Super Serum Advance Plus is formulated with time released L-ascorbic acid (vitamin C), performance maximizing copper tripeptide growth factor, and hydrating hyaluronic acid. Another big benefit is that it protects against UV damage, environmental damage and free radical damage using potent antioxidants. However, it lacks retinol. It also comes with a heavy price tag of $158 per piece. Despite this, it’s still highly recommended because of its all star list of ingredients. It’s also helpful that it comes with a 60 day money back guarantee. This means you can try it out and see if it works for you before committing to it.

Overall Rating (4.5)
Quality Rating: 9.1/10
Expert Rating: 9.0/10
Users Rating: 8.9/10

Advanced Scar Gel: by Mederma


Mederma’s unique triple action formula penetrates beneath the surface to seal in moisture, renew cells and aid formation of collagen. It requires you to simply apply it once a day to see results. This is one of the few products on this list that you can also find in stores. Its formula has been clinically proven in trials. However, Mederma doesn’t reveal their proprietary blend. While Mederma is reasonably priced, it’s important to note that if you find it doesn’t work for you, returning it requires you to jump through a bunch of hoops. Regardless of this, Medarma has a solid reputation and a long line of customers who back it up. It’s a solid choice if you’re looking for something more reasonable.

Overall Rating (4.5)
Quality Rating: 9.1/10
Expert Rating: 9.0/10
Users Rating: 8.9/10

Age Defense Retinol Complex 1.0 (1 fl. oz.): by SkinMedica


SkinMedica Age Defense Retinol Complex 1.0 is encapsulated with PhytoShield™ Complex, an antioxidant complex, enhancing skin texture and minimizing irritation. It also diminishes the appearance of fine lines and coarse wrinkles and enhances skin tone and texture. However, it’s meant for use only on your face and isn’t effective on scars on your body. It also comes with a heavy price tag of $93. But considering it has a 60 day money back guarantee, you’re free to try it out first before deciding if you’ll keep it. If you’re looking for a solution for scars on your face and want to enjoy an even skin tone, this is a great choice.

Overall Rating (4.5)
Quality Rating: 9.1/10
Expert Rating: 9.0/10
Users Rating: 8.9/10

Advanced Formula Scar Gel: by Kelo-Cote


Kelo-cote is a clinically-tested silicone scar gel that reduces the appearance of scars resulting from surgery, injury, burns, acne, insect bites, cuts and scrapes. It also reduces redness, softens and flattens raised scars. However, it uses a blend of only 2 ingredients and has not proven to provide additional health benefits to your skin. The good news is, it’s supported by a large number of positive customer reviews and can easily be purchased on Amazon.

Top 5